Atlanta Cold Cases Still Unsolved After Over 50 Years

---

📋 Case Summary

🕯️ Mary Shotwell Little

• Age: 25
• Disappeared: October 14, 1965, from Lenox Square Shopping Center, Atlanta, GA
• Occupation: Secretary at Citizens & Southern National Bank
• Status: Missing (Presumed murdered)
• Last Known Sightings: Witnesses later reported seeing a woman matching her description injured and accompanied by two men in North Carolina.
• Evidence: Bloodstained 1965 Mercury Comet found at Lenox Square; undergarments inside; car appeared to have been driven 41 miles. Her C&S charge card was used days later.

---

🕯️ Diane Shields

• Age: 22
• Murdered: May 19, 1967, in East Point, GA
• Occupation: Receptionist, previously held Mary’s job at the same bank
• Status: Homicide – Unsolved
• Last Seen: Leaving work in her Chevy Impala
• Evidence: Her body was found crammed in her car trunk, fully clothed, not robbed or assaulted. Cause of death: suffocation via scarf and paper shoved in her throat. She was engaged and had a wedding cookbook in the trunk.

---

🧾 Case Debriefing: Two Women, One Pattern—And One Chilling Confession

In the heart of Atlanta during the 1960s, two promising young women vanished under deeply suspicious and strangely similar circumstances. Mary Shotwell Little, a newlywed bank secretary, disappeared without a trace in 1965. Her unexplained absence sent shockwaves through the community, prompting extensive searches and media coverage. Mary was loved by many, and her sudden disappearance left her family and friends in a state of despair.

Diane Shields, a fellow bank employee who replaced Mary’s position and once lived with her roommates, was murdered less than two years later. This chilling turn of events not only intensified the fear within the community but also raised alarming questions about the safety of women in the city. The eerie similarities between the two cases led investigators to explore connections that went beyond mere coincidence. Though their cases were officially unlinked, many—including law enforcement—believed these cases were connected by something far more sinister than coincidence. Discussions circulated about patterns and potential suspects, with theories ranging from personal vendettas to organized crime.

Then came a prison letter in 1966 that reignited interest in both cases. A convicted killer claimed he knew what happened to Mary, naming names, describing locations, and revealing a kidnapping-for-hire scheme that could explain both tragedies. This shocking revelation added layers of complexity to an already tangled narrative and led authorities to reconsider the evidence they had initially dismissed. Investigators scrambled to follow up on the new leads provided in the letter, hoping it would bring clarity to two heart-wrenching stories that had haunted Atlanta for years.

As the investigation unfolded, the media buzzed with speculation, and the public grappled with the unsettling reality that a serial predator might be lurking in their midst. The haunting legacy of Mary Shotwell Little and Diane Shields continues to resonate, reminding us of the real-life consequences of violence and the importance of vigilance within communities. What truly happened to these women may never be fully understood, but their stories remain etched in the fabric of Atlanta’s history, serving as a chilling reminder of the darkness that sometimes lurks beneath the surface of everyday life.

---

🕵️‍♀️ Mary’s Disappearance: A Trail of Blood and Dust

On October 14, 1965, Mary met a friend for dinner at Lenox Square, excited to catch up and enjoy a night out. She never made it home, and as the hours turned into a restless night filled with concern, her absence became alarmingly palpable. The next day, her boss, noticing her unexplained absence at work, reported her missing to the authorities. Her car, a grey 1965 Comet, was found parked neatly at Lenox, its pristine condition unmistakably contrasted by the layer of red dust coating the exterior, hinting at its long-standing presence in that spot. The warm glow of the city lights, which had once welcomed her to an evening of laughter and joy, now served as a stark reminder of her sudden disappearance, leaving friends and family in a state of confusion and worry.

Inside, detectives found:

• Blood on multiple surfaces
• Her recently worn undergarments placed between the seats
• Her purse, raincoat, shoes, and wedding rings missing

The case quickly spiraled into panic. Atlanta police, the FBI, and even military search teams scoured the region, leaving no stone unturned in their desperate search for answers. Days turned into weeks as leads were chased down tirelessly, but the trail grew colder by the hour. Weeks later, her gas card was used in Raleigh and Charlotte, NC, raising the stakes and heightening the sense of urgency among investigators.

Two gas station attendants from a busy service station vividly remembered seeing a hurt, bleeding woman in a car with two men. The sight was alarming enough that one attendant had hesitated to approach the vehicle, sensing the tension in the air and the distress emanating from the woman. She wouldn’t get out, seemingly trapped in a perilous situation that kept her confined and silent as the men in the car talked in hushed tones.

The fear and uncertainty surrounding her fate deepened with every passing day—those who cared for her and those who were dedicated to finding her began to feel the weight of hopelessness. News crews set up outside the police station, covering the story and appealing to the public for any information, but the cases remained frustratingly cold.

And then—nothing. The investigation reached a standstill, leaving families devastated, and the community reeling. Questions went unanswered, and the mystery deepened, leaving a lingering, dark cloud over the case that no one could seem to disperse. Each day without new leads felt like an eternity, shrouded in a veil of uncertainty and fear, as the hope of finding her began to dwindle with each passing moment.

---

🔥 A Bombshell in Prison: The Stargel Confession

In September 1966, a letter arrived from Reidsville State Prison, written by Larry Stargel, a 23-year-old convicted murderer who was serving a lengthy sentence for his crime. His unexpected correspondence captured the attention of law enforcement, as he expressed a desire to discuss the troubling case surrounding Mary’s disappearance, a case that had left the community in turmoil. Stargel claimed he possessed information that could shed light on the events leading up to Mary’s vanishing, raising both hope and skepticism among investigators who were keenly aware of his criminal background yet intrigued by the prospect of new leads after months of fruitless searching.

In a 19-page confession, Stargel told Lt. Jack Perry that:

• He had been friends with a man named Gerald “Jerry” Mason, who showed him Mary’s C&S bank card.
• Mason and another man were paid $5,000 each to kidnap Mary in a blackmail plot.
• Mary was held captive in a house in the mountains near Mount Holly, NC, beaten and tied up.
• Stargel heard an argument and later saw a man stab Mary under her left ear with a fishing knife, wrapping her in a rug and hiding her body.
• They claimed, “She won’t be found,” and taunted Stargel with the truth behind their actions.

FAA records later confirmed that the man Stargel named as the killer worked at the Mount Holly Water Department—and had time-stamped hours covering the day of Mary’s disappearance. These records provided a crucial link between the suspect and the timeline of events surrounding Mary’s case, offering a glimmer of hope for justice in a situation that had long been shrouded in mystery.

Yet despite this deeply detailed confession—initialed but never signed—and the evidence aligning with Stargel’s timeline, the FBI marked the case as “incomplete.” This decision left many questioning the integrity of the investigation and considering the implications of such a label. How could a confession so specific, backed by corroborative evidence, lead to a stagnation in the case? The incongruence of the FBI’s conclusion with the tangible leads raised concerns not only about the investigation itself but also about the potential for accountability.

As public interest grew, so did scrutiny around the processes and decision-making within the FBI. The mounting pressure highlighted the need for transparency and diligence when unraveling complex cases like Mary’s, where lives were irrevocably impacted. Questions lingered about what more could be done to bring closure to a family that had already endured so much suffering, and whether the systems in place were adequately serving their purpose in the pursuit of justice.

---

🕯️ Diane Shields: Murdered 18 Months Later

On May 19, 1967, Diane left work in her blue and white Chevy Impala, a car she cherished for its unique style, and never arrived home. Her coworkers noticed her cheerful demeanor that day, completely unaware it would be the last time they would see her. Hours later, her car was discovered parked outside a laundry on Sylvan Road in East Point, raising immediate concern among family and friends. The sight of her beloved vehicle, with blood dripping ominously from the back, sent shockwaves through the community, igniting fears and questions about her safety and the events that led to this chilling discovery.

Inside the trunk:

• Diane’s body, upside down, crammed tightly between a spare tire and cardboard box, her limbs contorted in an unnatural position as if in a desperate struggle for escape.
• A scarf and a piece of paper shoved down her throat, creating a suffocating and desperate situation that left her gasping for air as she struggled to understand the gravity of her predicament.
• Her engagement ring still on her finger, a symbol of the love and commitment she once cherished deeply.
• A copy of Betty Crocker’s New Dinner for Two, featuring a collection of delicious and easy-to-follow recipes designed for intimate meals shared between couples, ensuring both variety and simplicity in preparing culinary delights. [ Such a weird thing to be left in the trunk with her if you ask me.]

She had not been assaulted or robbed, and despite the chaos that occasionally surrounded her, her life was taking a beautiful turn. She was engaged to a wonderful partner, who brought joy and comfort into her life. Together, they spent long evenings dreaming about the future, planning a vibrant July wedding filled with laughter, family, and love. The thought of walking down the aisle, surrounded by friends and loved ones, filled her heart with excitement, as she envisioned the life they would build together afterward, filled with adventures and cherished memories.

---

🧩 Unnerving Parallels Between the Two Women

• Same Bank: Both worked at Citizens & Southern National Bank
• Shared Social Circle: Diane lived with Mary’s old roommates
• Mysterious Flowers: Both received anonymous roses at work
• Confessions & Secrets: Diane told a close friend she was working undercover to help police solve Mary’s case
• Same Fate? Diane became increasingly secretive in the months before her death—often vanishing for hours without explanation.

“They’re connected, no question.”
—Melvin Banks, Lead Detective on Diane’s case

Some believed Diane knew too much about the dark secrets lurking within their workplace, secrets that could unravel lives and careers. Others feared that a killer was still hiding among them, perhaps observing their every move, which only intensified their anxiety. Even FBI agent Jim Ponder, though initially skeptical of the notion that any real danger existed, admitted with a grave nod that the women who lived with both Mary and Diane were “scared to death.” Their fear was palpable, woven into the very fabric of their daily lives, as they moved cautiously through the hallways, exchanging worried glances and whispering about the unsettling atmosphere that had settled over their once-peaceful environment. The uncertainty hung thick in the air, creating an atmosphere charged with tension and fear that no one could easily shake off.

---

🕯️ Lost Files, Lost Justice

Perhaps the most disturbing fact?
Both case files mysteriously vanished, leaving behind a chilling void in the investigation.
No records remain, and the trail of evidence has gone cold, making it nearly impossible for authorities to piece together the events. No leads have ever led to arrests, which only deepens the sense of injustice and frustration surrounding these unresolved cases, haunting the families involved and provoking questions that linger in the shadows.

“There were a lot of things about this case that never made sense.”
—Jim Ponder, FBI Liaison

And yet the fear, the silence, and the long-buried trauma still ripple through the city, weaving a complex tapestry of unrest and anxiety that residents grapple with daily. The echoes of past struggles resonate in the hearts of the inhabitants, each hushed whisper carrying memories of sorrow and resilience. As shadows stretch across the streets, the weight of unspoken stories looms large, leaving an indelible mark on the community’s psyche, while a palpable tension hangs in the air, reminding everyone that healing is a journey fraught with challenges and uncertainty.

---

📻 Want to Know More?

Investigative journalist Jessica Noll spent a year uncovering both cases in her gripping podcast series:
🎙️ 5 Roses: The Untold Story of Diane & Mary

If you know something—anything—call:

• Atlanta PD: (404) 614-6544
• East Point PD: (404) 761-2177
• FBI Atlanta Office: (770) 216-3000
• Crime Stoppers: (404) 577-TIPS

---

☕ Final Sip: Coincidence or Cover-Up?

Two women. Two vanished files. One man in prison claimed he witnessed it all—yet the truth remains buried deeper than any construction site behind the airport. This is not just a case of disappearance; it’s a tangled web of secrets and unanswered questions that seem to stretch on indefinitely.

Were Diane and Mary victims of a random predator? The thought chills the spine. Or could it be that their fates were intertwined with a more sinister bank-connected conspiracy, involving powerful individuals willing to go to any lengths to keep the truth hidden? The stakes are high, and the implications of their disappearance reach far beyond the surface.

Perhaps, there’s something worse lurking in the shadows, waiting to be uncovered. As investigators dig into the case, every clue leads to more questions than answers. Why were the files associated with their cases never found? What exactly did the man in prison see that made him so adamant about his testimony? Each revelation seems to only deepen the mystery, raising the specter of corruption and collusion.

In a world where trust is a fragile commodity, and truth is often obscured by fear and silence, Diane and Mary’s story may serve as a stark reminder of the lengths people will go to protect their secrets. As the investigation unfolds, the community is left to grapple with the unsettling possibility that the truth may never come to light. Will justice prevail, or will the memories of two vanished women fade into obscurity, buried forever alongside the files that held their stories? The answers lie shrouded in mystery, waiting to be uncovered by those brave enough to seek them out.

Coming up next Tea & Mystery:
➡️ Case No. 3: A Serial Killer Hidden in Plain Sight in Macon’s Underbelly…

—
Much love and many blessings,
Mrs. B
🕯️ Tea & Mystery |The B-Side

🔍 Truth brews in silence. Let’s sip and uncover it together.